That big Janto debate, in summary, then...

[tencrush]

Thank everyone for jumping into my debate/ramblings about Jack/Ianto, just a point or two to clarify and summarise:

• I don't have a problem with Gwen, or Jack being in love with or loving Gwen. I don't think it detracts from his relationship with Ianto and I don't think Ianto is some poor naive lamb who is hurt by Jack looking at or loving other people. I'm pretty sure Ianto realises that getting involved with Jack could mean entering into a polyamorous relationship, and I assume that in entering into a relationship with Jack, Ianto accepts that. I've never thought of Ianto as naive or stupid. He knows what he's doing.



• The problem I do have, is in the fact that they are SHOWING us Jack MOONING over Gwen, and they are showing us ABSOLUTELY NO MOONING over Ianto. In doing that, whilst slowly showing us that Ianto is PRETTY DAMNED IN LOVE (The speech in Adam, the coming out scene this episode, Ianto is getting pretty invested into this relationship, if you hadn't noticed), they're not showing ANY OF THE SAME from Jack. Now Jack already is Ianto's boss, he's older than Ianto, and, this being Ianto's first guy-guy thing, Jack is VASTLY MORE EXPERIENCED as well. As they start to show us how emotionally involved Ianto is, with no reciprocation on that level from Jack, the relationship becomes more and more uncomfortable to watch because the power is starting to shift towards Jack so heavily. Harassment. I had this issue with them in season 1, as well. That niggling feeling I couldn't quite shift that Jack was manipulating Ianto with sex, because Jack figured it would be advantageous to redirect Ianto's obviously passionate loyalties towards Jack, by means of his magickal futuristic cock.



• Or, to put it another way, and quote one of the commenters on the previous post: "isn't sleeping with someone who has way deep emotional feelings for you, which you clearly don't reciprocate as intensely, still pretty icky?" No matter which way you look at it, yeah, that's a little bit icky.



• And to quote myself, another general niggle I have is this: The playing up of their sex games is starting to detract from any possible hints of depth to the relationship and is distracting me to the point of annoyance. Jokes are one thing, kink is fine, but you can take things too far, and that point has more or less been reached, unless you give me some depth to balance it out.



• On a seperate note, I have never once said Gareth David-Lloyd is fat. I've been making pie jokes for a few weeks, because he's obviously gained a few pounds and he's one of those people unfortunate enough to have any weight gain, no matter how slight, show up around the face area, so he needs to watch himself. I only say it out of love and I would still happily FUCK HIM UNTIL HE BREAKS. Just to make that clear.



• I do have a serious observation to make about Jack's implied attitude of fucking the men and marrying the women, but I'll probably save it for torch_wood or torchwood_meta or something, because it's something that seems to be becoming an issue with a lot of people.

Thank you all for listening.

Comments

[cassandraterra.livejournal.com]

I agree with you except with Gareth's weight gain. I think it makes him look cuter! I want to pinch his cheeks!


Sorry for the fandom wank. It comes with the territory.

[kateorman.livejournal.com]

Plus! John Barrowman's love handles are the cutest thing ever.

[tencrush]

I really don't get that, doesn't Barrownman make your Gaydar go off to such an extent that you cease to register whether or not he's attractive? That's what happens to me with tey Ghey, generally, especially now that I'm into Reproduction.

[kateorman.livejournal.com]

Crikey! No!

[tencrush]

Hmmm. Weird.

[kateorman.livejournal.com]

Although I admit the current eyebrow catastrophe is a little off-putting.

[tencrush]

AHHHAAAHAHAHAHAHALOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL!!!!!

[seymorebutz.livejournal.com]

JOHN, LEAVE YOUR FACE ALONE!!

[erinnthered.livejournal.com]

I came here from Torchwood Three, and I agree with pretty much everything you've said. You put it so much better than I ever could. But I had to comment here...

ITA! I just can't go for teh ghey. They're completely off my radar, sexually. Which has been a good thing, since I worked in theatre for a long time. Barrowman is pretty, yes, but he does nothing to me.

Also, on #5...I worry that it's not just the pies. It may also be the booze. Seriously, too much is really not a good thing. But he's still totally fuckable! And a big HEE to the hairline mention. I never thought I'd see the day.

[tencrush]

Me neither. He's just... gay. That's it.

As for Gareth, I'd totally do him until he saw double, but I'm well aware that he would smell of pie, booze and fags. But I'd still do him.

[erinnthered.livejournal.com]

I'm well aware that he would smell of pie, booze and fags.

Okay, so that actually sounds kinda hot...okay really hot. I'm weird, I know.

[tencrush]

As long as it's not steak and kidney, that's pretty hawt, yeah. If it's steak and kidney, the deal's off.

[erinnthered.livejournal.com]

See, I can do steak and kidney. I just can't do Marlboros. Their the foulest smelling cigarettes on Earth.

[tencrush]

Well, yeah, alright then, Marlboros or Lucky Strike, the deal's off too. Lucky Strikes smell of machine parts. Taste like 'em too.

[erinnthered.livejournal.com]

But they're toasted!

Have you seen Mad Men? I know it's a real slogan, but still. Mad Men is one of the best things on TV in a long time. It didn't help my smoking habit though.

And yes, Lucky Strikes are also pretty foul.

[tencrush]

It is on the beeb at 10 or something? Which is 11 my time, which means I fall asleep during the first five minutes of watching it in bed. I have to, my child wakes up again at 1, so I take what I can get.

So no, I have yet to see more than the credits of Mad Men.

[erinnthered.livejournal.com]

Understandable. A six month old? I don't have kids, but I sympathize.

And Mad Men? Find it, download it, get it from somewhere. It's worth it.