Indeed it would. You're quoting from two threads, not one, for a start. The first thread - your first four comments - has nine comments in response to the OP and each other, all variously jeering at Tencrush and explicitly critiquing her parenting decisions, including information about her children that I certainly didn't know. One of the responses you cite asks "can we not talk about her kid" - there's no response to that, modly or otherwise. Nor is it a suggestion that the criticism of Tencrush is in any way per se invalid, nor are any of the other comments you've quoted from that particular thread.
The other four comments you found came from the longer thread, a few posts below. The responses get pretty garbled in a mishmash of jeering at Tencrush and me, jointly and severally, but my rough count gives at least 35 attacking Tencrush, 20 or so raging against me, and upwards of 30 or so attacking the commenters criticising the meme, including the ones you quoted.
If that seems to indicate a tolerable balance to you, or you find that indicative of a meme where 'many' are challenging the hate and those challenges are being fairly debated, rather than deleted or dogpiled, then I can see that you would feel the meme is a good place in which to participate, and support for / participation in it doesn't reflect poorly on those who do. I don't see it that way myself, no.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2009-11-24 10:47 pm (UTC)The other four comments you found came from the longer thread, a few posts below. The responses get pretty garbled in a mishmash of jeering at Tencrush and me, jointly and severally, but my rough count gives at least 35 attacking Tencrush, 20 or so raging against me, and upwards of 30 or so attacking the commenters criticising the meme, including the ones you quoted.
If that seems to indicate a tolerable balance to you, or you find that indicative of a meme where 'many' are challenging the hate and those challenges are being fairly debated, rather than deleted or dogpiled, then I can see that you would feel the meme is a good place in which to participate, and support for / participation in it doesn't reflect poorly on those who do. I don't see it that way myself, no.