tencrush: (oral fixation)
tencrush ([personal profile] tencrush) wrote2008-06-02 04:07 pm

Mad Larry

I don't really know much about Lawrence Miles, and just as I was about to sit down and actually read his blog which I skip-read yesterday, HIS ENTIRE BEING SEEMS TO HAVE DISAPPEARED OFF THE FACE OF THE INTERNETS.

This makes me sad because I wanted to read his Space Library script. Anyone saved it???

Anyway, like I said his blog was a bit tl;dr, but I seem to remember the gist being that Steven Moffat made Larry an alcoholic, the Whovian powers that be point and laugh at Larry a lot and Neil Gaiman, who got namechecked for NO APPARENT REASON is, according to Larry "a stinking parasite who'll sink to any depths in his quest to make goth-girls cop off with him". Yah, I managed to save that quote for slanderous luls. And Moffat has some sort of sekrit evol Scottish powers or something.

What I DO remember, and it's something I've read elsewhere as well, is Larry's critique of Silence in the Library, which seemed to boil down to "OMG he puts a kid in to appeal to the kiddies and he puts in innuendo to appeal to the adults and he puts in geekspeak to appeal to the nerds, HOW FUCKING WRONG AND EVIL IS THAT???"

Seriously, though, what the FUCK is wrong with that? I see Moffat getting slated a lot for appealing to a wide audience, and I just don't get it. Moffat is clever enough to write in a way that appeals to damn near everybody. Fuck, man, did I miss a meeting somewhere, surely that's FUCKING GREAT. Isn't it?

ETA: Oh, he's back. Must have just been the silly conspiracy theorist in me thinking Gaiman had him offed or something.

[identity profile] xanister.livejournal.com 2008-06-02 03:00 pm (UTC)(link)
I just skip-read through that too and it seems really, really childish.

One thing I've always loved about Moffat is that he does appeal to a wide audience. I still introduce people to Doctor Who through Empty Child/Doctor dances since if nothing else it's a good scary story.

Poor Gaiman though, I kind of wonder what happened that made him write that way about him.
ext_13838: Sorrow tearing her hair, with refrain from Deor. (Default)

[identity profile] edithmatilda.livejournal.com 2008-06-02 03:12 pm (UTC)(link)
I think mainly Neil Gaiman has committed the heinous sin of being much better at being what Mad Larry wants to be than Mad Larry can ever dream of. And getting more sex. I tend to think of that blog as being a lot like the nasty bits of one's brain that one chooses not to share because of the horrifying shame of one's own lameness. Except that he's missed out that last bit.

[identity profile] baby-werewolf.livejournal.com 2008-06-02 08:11 pm (UTC)(link)
Don't you just wish Gaiman had had him offed...

[identity profile] qthewetsprocket.livejournal.com 2008-06-02 09:20 pm (UTC)(link)
neil has sekrit hobbit powerz. do not offend teh hobbit, or lo, he will not share his elevensies with you.

seriously, though, i'm with everyone else here - mr miles is annoyed with mr moffat and mr gaiman for both being much better writers than he is. end of story.

[identity profile] descrime.livejournal.com 2008-06-03 02:37 am (UTC)(link)
I actually read his script before I saw Silence in the Library, and I have to say that I think it is a solid script. It's much better than the Sontaran Stratagem/Poison Sky debacle which I find painful to watch or the Planet of the Ood and the Pompeii thing both of which suffered extreme unoriginality. However, having then watched SinL, Moffat clearly wins this match up. The thing I like about Moffat, the thing which none of the other writers for Who seem to grasp, is how to keep the audience confused (in a good way). I'm hoping for more of that when Moffat takes the reins.

And actually, I really hope there aren't any overarching plots anymore. Maybe it's because I'm American, but at 13 episodes, I perfectly fine with standalone episodes and the occasional two-parter for a couple of seasons. Maybe then we could get a companion that lasts for more than one season and doesn't suffer huge mental trauma.

[identity profile] ionlylurkhere.livejournal.com 2008-06-03 06:59 am (UTC)(link)
I see Moffat getting slated a lot for appealing to a wide audience

From most people it is a bit mad, but Miles is the guy who writes stuff about how Ally McBeal and Big Brother are Time Lord culture-deadening weapons. So for him it probably is evil.

Have you managed to get the Mad Larry script? 'Cos if you want it I can email it you.