Seeing as I didn't like the pirate episode at all, I would have preferred this third. Though, the flesh becoming wood and returning to duplicating Amy would have been strange.

I thought the concept was good, but the execution of the idea was poor in several spots. And I absolutely hated at the end when the mom returns home and they lie to her and keep the kid's origins "just between us boys". Haha, why do women need to know the truth? They can just let the men handle everything important.

I sincerely hope next week Rory does not actually get to choose his wife's personality.