None of it makes any sense, Kate, and I think there's things at play that we aren't aware of. If I were to speculate, I'd say that in spite of the reports, JB was actually not on board with a TW S4, and giving him this and tonight's angst effectively makes Jack incapable of being Torchwood's leader. Leaving us with a possibility of a S4, which would essentially be, yes, Rose Tyler: Earth Defender. But with Gwen.